The Two Types of Mathematicians

Oct 18, 2021 | Location West County

The Two Types of Mathematicians

Apr 29 · 4 min read

You may have heard of Freeman Dyson, a 20th-century mathematician who made enormous progress in quantum electrodynamics, along with a variety of other fields such a number theory. He worked extensively with Richard Feynman, translating his thoughts into mathematical equations. Dyson is also known for his big ideas about the future of humanity, such as the Dyson Sphere and how we could escape the heat death of the universe. He was also a self-described frog.

Wait, a frog? In his 2008 Einstein Lecture, Dyson described his categorization of mathematicians and physicists as members of two large groups: frogs and birds. To define these groups, he provided two prominent thinkers from the 17th century. René Descartes was a quintessential bird, flying high over many fields. Dyson said they “delight in concepts that unify our thinking and bring together diverse problems from different parts of the landscape.” Descartes certainly fit this description, working to combine algebra and geometry in the now-standard Cartesian Plane.

In contrast, Francis Bacon perfectly embodies the traits of a frog, similar to Dyson himself. Bacon was a strong proponent of gathering data and making empirical observations. Frogs are those who only look at their immediate surroundings and work forward. According to Dyson, “they delight in the details of particular objects, and they solve problems one at a time.” Mathematics, being both broad and deep, desperately needs both.

Einstein and Wiles

Time and time again, we’ve seen advancements in math only made through the combined work of frogs and birds. Albert Einstein, perhaps the most famous bird, relied on the work of countless frogs in order to formulate his theory of relativity. Non-euclidean geometry had been in development for over a century, pushed by GaussLobachevsky, and Riemann. These mathematicians, among others, dedicated their lives to carving out the details alternate geometries. Only with these details was Einstein able to bridge the gap between geometry and reality in the form of relativity, changing our world forever.

Simon Singh’s excellent book describing the various birds and frogs leading up to Wiles’ proof.

Let’s look at another, more recent, example. In 1995, Andrew Wiles published his proof of Fermat’s Last Theorem. There are countless articles on this subject, including an incredible book, so I won’t go into the details. When describing his efforts, he said

You enter the first room of the mansion and it’s completely dark. In complete blackness. You stumble around bumping into the furniture, but you gradually learn where each piece of furniture is. Finally, after six months or so, you find the light switch, you turn it on, and suddenly it’s all illuminated. You can see exactly where you were. Then you move into the next room and spend another six months in the dark. So each of these breakthroughs, while sometimes they’re momentary, sometimes over a period of a day or two, they are the culmination of — and couldn’t exist without — the many months of stumbling around in the dark that preceded them.” Source

To me, this is indicative of Wiles being a frog. He was immensely interested in details, and stuck with one particular problem for eight years! However, Wiles disagreed and rejects both labels.

“Well, I don’t feel like either. I’m certainly not a bird — unifying different fields. I think of frogs as jumping a lot. I think I’m very, very focused. I don’t know what the animal analogy is, but I think I’m not a frog in the sense that I enjoy the nearby landscape. I’m very, very concentrated on the problem I happen to work on and I am very selective. And I find it very hard to even take my mind off it enough to look at any of the flowers around, so I don’t think that either of the descriptions quite fits.” Source

Perhaps a slower, more stagnant animal would be more fitting for Wiles, maybe a sloth?

Other Categorizations

In fact, there are a number of mathematicians who reject these labels and find them to be too limiting. This article, along with extensive discussion about birds and frogs, proposes a third category: beavers. This third groups tends to focus more on computation and puzzles, like those problems found in combinatorics and computational theory. Beavers have become more prominent within the last century due to the rise of computers.

Another attempt to categorize mathematics, different from the frogs and birds entirely, is proposed by David Mumford. In this page, he summarized his four groups: Explorers, Alchemists, Wrestlers, and Detectives. His method of separating these types comes from where they derive excitement. I’d encourage you to read his explanations and see which group you fall into!

While there is no perfect way to classify these brilliant thinkers, it certainly is helpful to have some structure in which to work.

 

WRITTEN BY

Former math/physics student now studying atmospheric science. I like everything related to complex systems! Avid fantasy reader and runner on the side.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Locations near
ME
Ashburn 0.93 mi
43330 Junction Plaza
#160
Ashburn, VA 20147
Sterling 4.07 mi
44 Pidgeon Hill Drive
#100
Sterling, VA 20165
Leesburg 5.69 mi
521 E Market St
#B
Leesburg, VA 20176
Herndon 7.66 mi
2465 Centreville Road
#J2
Herndon, VA 20171
Stone Ridge 7.88 mi
42020 Village Center Plaza
#100
Stone Ridge, VA 20105
Reston 8.62 mi
1424 North Point Village Center
Reston, VA 20194
Purcellville 12.72 mi
1020 E Main St
Ste L
Purcellville, VA 20132
North Potomac 13.58 mi
12150 Darnestown Rd
Gaithersburg, MD 20878
Centreville 14.52 mi
5959 Centreville Crest Ln
Centreville, VA 20121
Fairfax 14.67 mi
11891 Grand Commons Ave
Fairfax, VA 22030
Potomac 14.98 mi
10232 River Road
#B
Potomac, MD 20854
Germantown MD 15.03 mi
12800 Middlebrook Road
Germantown, MD 20874
Tysons 15.45 mi
328 Maple Ave E
#A
Vienna, VA 22180
Haymarket 17.87 mi
15125 Washington St
Haymarket, VA 20169
Rockville 18.19 mi
20 Courthouse Square
#106
Rockville, MD 20850
Mclean 18.23 mi
1320 Old Chain Bridge Road
Suite #190
McLean, VA 22101
Gaithersburg 18.71 mi
9132 Rothbury Drive
Gaithersburg, MD 20886
North Bethesda 20.42 mi
5268 Nicholson Ln
#N
Kensington, MD 20895
Falls Church 20.59 mi
6674 Arlington Blvd
Falls Church, VA 22042
Manassas 20.65 mi
9722 Liberia Ave
Manassas, VA 20110
Bristow 20.71 mi
12705 Braemar Village Pz
Bristow, VA 20136
Burke 20.82 mi
9411 Old Burke Lake Rd
#C
Burke, VA 22015
Bethesda 21.3 mi
4918 Fairmont Ave
Bethesda, MD 20814
Annandale 21.64 mi
7000 Columbia Pike
Annandale, VA 22003
Damascus 22.77 mi
9815 Main St
Damascus, MD 20872
Arlington, VA 23.29 mi
4801 1st St N
Arlington, VA 22203
Cathedral Heights 23.51 mi
3706 Macomb St NW
Washington, D.C., DC 20016
Olney 23.96 mi
18157 Village Center Dr
Olney, MD 20832
Downtown Silver Spring 24.94 mi
1133 East West Highway
Silver Spring, MD 20910
Lorton 25.06 mi
9027 Silverbrook Rd
#A
Fairfax Station, VA 22039
West Washington 25.69 mi

Washington, DC 20009
Alexandria City 25.7 mi
4605 Duke Street
Alexandria, VA 22304
Lake Ridge 26.5 mi
12473 Dillingham Square
Lake Ridge, VA 22192
Frederick North 26.7 mi
905 W. 7th Street
Frederick, MD 21701
Northern Silver Spring 26.75 mi
732 Cloverly Street
Silver Spring, MD 20905
Alexandria 27.17 mi
6483 Old Beulah Street
Alexandria, VA 22315
Warrenton 27.42 mi
512 Fletcher Drive
Warrenton, VA 20186
Mount Airy 28.24 mi
411 E Ridgeville Blvd
Mt Airy, MD 21771
Capitol Hill DC 28.48 mi
621 Pennsylvania Ave SE
1st-floor unit
Washington, DC 20003
Dale City 28.99 mi
5512 Staples Mill Plaza
Dale City, VA 22193
Mount Vernon 29.66 mi
7696 H Richmond Hwy
Alexandria, VA 22306
Beltsville 30.89 mi
10914 Baltimore Ave
#B
Beltsville, MD 20705
Clarksville 31.56 mi
12250 Clarksville Pike
#D
Clarksville, MD 21029
Laurel 35.02 mi
10095 Washington Blvd N
#136
Laurel, MD 20723
Woodmore 35.27 mi
9101 Woodmore Centre Drive
Lanham, MD 20706
Glenn Dale 35.83 mi
10559 Greenbelt Rd
Lanham, MD 20706
Sykesville 36.57 mi
1207 Liberty Rd.
#D-104
Sykesville, MD 21784
Ellicott City 37.11 mi
3290 Pine Orchard Lane
#B
Ellicott City, MD 21042
Winchester 37.62 mi
2512 S Pleasant Valley Rd
Winchester, VA 22601
Columbia 38.19 mi
8827 Centre Park Drive
#F
Columbia, MD 21045
Stafford 39.58 mi
263 Garrisonville Road
#104
Stafford, VA 22554
Bowie 41.26 mi
15231 Hall Rd
Bowie, MD 20721
Waldorf 42.24 mi
3022 Festival Way
Waldorf, MD 20601
Crofton 42.6 mi
1153 Route 3 North
#120
Crofton, MD 21054
Owings Mills 44.15 mi
9433 Common Brook Rd #100
Owings Mills, MD 21117
Pikesville 46.84 mi
1433 Reisterstown Rd
Pikesville, MD 21208
Dunkirk 49.92 mi
10735 Town Center Blvd
#7
Dunkirk, MD 20754