What if a small misunderstanding in elementary school could shape a child’s entire math journey?
A study published in Frontiers in Psychology reveals that early number misconceptions don’t just disappear—they persist, often resurfacing in different ways as students progress through school.
For instance, a student might believe multiplication always makes numbers bigger or that a larger denominator means a larger fraction. Such ideas seem logical at first but can cause major roadblocks.
So, where do these misconceptions come from, and how can students overcome them?
This guide will explore what misconceptions are as well as why they happen. We’ll also break down common math misconceptions in elementary and middle school and practical ways to correct them.
Meet the Top-Rated Math Tutors in Hyde Park, Cincinnati
Although errors and misconceptions are related, they shouldn’t be used interchangeably.
An error is a one-time mistake—like misreading a problem, miscalculating, or getting distracted. A student might write 7 + 4 = 10 simply because they were rushing.
Errors are inconsistent and tend to disappear with practice.
Misconceptions, however, run deeper. They stem from incorrect reasoning about how math works. A student who believes a larger denominator means a larger fraction (e.g., thinking \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{8} \) is greater than \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{4} \) because 8 is bigger than 4) isn’t just making a mistake—they’ve internalized a faulty rule.
Misconceptions are persistent and can remain unnoticed for years, influencing how new concepts are learned.
Errors tend to self-correct with practice, but misconceptions require deliberate rethinking.
More repetition won’t fix a misunderstanding—it only reinforces the wrong idea. Correcting misconceptions means breaking down faulty reasoning and rebuilding a clearer, more accurate understanding.
Students instinctively apply familiar ideas in ways that seem logical but don’t always hold true.
Math misconceptions don’t appear out of nowhere—they form when students apply faulty reasoning to new concepts. In other words, the brain naturally looks for patterns, but sometimes it latches onto the wrong ones.
A study published in The Journal of the Learning Sciences explains that students build new knowledge on top of what they already understand, which can lead to misconceptions when prior ideas don’t fully align with new concepts.
To illustrate this, many students mistakenly see the equal sign as a signal to perform a calculation rather than as a symbol of equivalence, which might lead to errors in algebraic reasoning.
Misconceptions in math can also arise when students overgeneralize rules or rely on surface-level patterns instead of deeper reasoning.
Additional insights from the study suggest that these misunderstandings often develop because students instinctively apply familiar ideas in ways that seem logical but don’t always hold true across different mathematical concepts.
For instance, a student who grasps that multiplication makes whole numbers larger might wrongly assume this holds true in all cases, resulting in confusion when faced with fraction multiplication (e.g., \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{2} \times \frac{1}{2} = \frac{1}{4} \)).
If you notice these misconceptions in your child, they aren’t signs of a lack of ability. Rather, they show an active effort to make sense of math using familiar ideas.
Misconceptions aren’t failures—they’re opportunities to strengthen understanding and build a more solid foundation.
Before misconceptions can be corrected, they first need to be identified. Oftentimes, students don’t realize they’re holding onto flawed ideas about math, and these misunderstandings often go unnoticed in a traditional classroom setting.
Simply spotting wrong answers isn’t enough—the key is to understand the reasoning behind them.
This is where diagnostic assessment plays a key role. Rather than just measuring what a student gets right or wrong, effective assessment uncovers the thought processes that lead to mistakes.
Schedule a Free Assessment at Mathnasium of Hyde Park
As highlighted in Adding It Up: Helping Children Learn Mathematics, assessments should not only evaluate learning but also guide instruction, helping to pinpoint where misconceptions arise.
Beyond identifying errors, mistakes should be used as springboards for deeper understanding. Instead of simply correcting a wrong answer, students should be guided to rethink their reasoning and recognize why their initial logic didn’t hold up.
Cognitive psychologist Robert Siegler and education researcher Hugues Lortie-Forgues argue in their 2017 study that struggles with rational number arithmetic often stem from underlying misunderstandings rather than simple computational errors, and overcoming them requires helping students reframe their thought process rather than just supplying the correct answer.
Collaborative learning also plays an important role in addressing misconceptions. When students discuss their reasoning with peers, they are forced to articulate their thought processes, confront differing perspectives, and refine their understanding.
According to the Education Endowment Foundation (EEF), structured group work helps students identify and correct misconceptions through discussion and shared problem-solving. This approach makes sure that misconceptions aren’t only corrected but replaced with a stronger conceptual foundation.
Structured group work helps students identify and correct misconceptions through discussion and shared problem-solving
Connecting math to real-world situations enables students to replace misconceptions with a clearer, more intuitive understanding of mathematical concepts.
Research from Learning and Teaching Early Math: The Learning Trajectories Approach demonstrates that students achieve stronger learning outcomes when engaged in meaningful, practical contexts.
For instance, applying fractions to measure recipe ingredients or calculate shopping discounts reinforces accurate reasoning and transforms abstract ideas into concrete, accessible knowledge.
In elementary school, misconceptions often take root as students encounter concepts that challenge their early number sense.
Research from Siegler & Lortie-Forgues (2017) highlights that these misunderstandings, especially in grades 2-5, stem from applying whole-number logic to new ideas like fractions and decimals.
Here are some of the biggest examples seen in young learners, along with strategies to set them straight.
For instance, a student might insist \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{8} \) is greater than \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{4} \) because 8 is bigger than 4, a pattern that holds with whole numbers but flips with fractions.
To address this, grab a piece of paper, a strip of dough, or even a pizza slice—something they can see and touch. Split one into four equal sections to show \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{4} \), then another into eight for \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{8} \).
Lay them next to each other and ask: which piece looks bigger?
They’ll see \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{4} \) is larger, and that hands-on comparison can shift their thinking from “bigger number, bigger value” to “more pieces, smaller size.”
A child might assume that \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{2} \times \frac{1}{2} = \frac{1}{4} \) gives something more than \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{2} \) , not \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{4} \) , since they’ve learned 2 × 3 equals 6 and expect multiplication to grow things every time. It’s a rule that works until fractions enter the picture.
In such cases, start with something real they can handle, like a small square of paper or a cookie. Cut it in half to show \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{2} \), then cut that half in half again to reveal \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{4} \).
Point out how the piece keeps getting smaller, not bigger, and let them try it with a few examples—like \( \displaystyle \frac{1}{3} \times \frac{1}{3} \).
Seeing and touching the result helps them realize multiplication doesn’t always mean “more,” especially when the numbers are less than one.
A student could argue that 0.123 is greater than 0.5 because it’s got three digits to 0.5’s one, treating it like a race where more means better, not checking what those digits actually stand for.
Pull out a ruler or draw a line on paper, marking it from 0 to 1. Put 0.5 in the middle, then have them guess where 0.123 goes—closer to 0 or 1.
Plot it out together and watch them see 0.123 sits way before 0.5. This visual trick shows it’s not about how many digits you write, but where the number lands in the grand scheme.
Students adopt new concepts best through experience. A simple ruler allows them to observe the unintuitive differences between decimals.
In middle school, math misconceptions often surface as students tackle more abstract concepts like algebra and proportions, typically in grades 6-8. These aren’t fleeting errors but deep-seated ideas that grow from earlier learning, now tested by new challenges.
Here are some frequent misconceptions you might encounter at this stage, along with hands-on ways to guide students toward clarity.
A student sees an equation like 5 + 3 = __ + 2 and writes 8 in the blank, interpreting the equals sign as a signal to calculate the sum of 5 + 3 and ignoring the equivalence between both sides of the equation.
In this case, it’s important to emphasize that the equals sign represents equivalence, meaning both sides of the equation must have the same value. Use balance scales as a visual aid to show that each side must "weigh" the same.
For example, rewrite 5 + 3 = __ as 8 = ___ + 2, then ask students what number makes both sides equal (answer: 6). Practice with equations where the unknown appears on both sides to reinforce this concept.
A student might calculate 7−(−3) and write 4, incorrectly treating the subtraction of a negative as a regular subtraction.
Use a number line to visually demonstrate that subtracting a negative is equivalent to adding its positive counterpart. Start at 7 on the number line, then explain that subtracting −3 means moving three steps to the right (adding 3).
This results in 7 + 3 = 10. Reinforce this with real-world examples, such as a bank account—removing a debt is like subtracting a negative amount: if you no longer owe $3, your overall balance increases by $3.
A student assumes x in x > 3 must be just 4 (or one number), not seeing it could be 5, 10, or even 3.1, thinking variables always pin down to one answer like in basic equations.
Write x > 3 and ask: what could x be? Test 4 (works), 5 (works), and 2 (doesn’t). Then graph it on a number line. Shade everything past 3 with an open dot. Show how x = 3 + 1 or x < 10 gives one value or a range too. This opens their eyes to variables as flexible—sometimes a point, sometimes a spread—depending on the problem.
Mathnasium is a math-only learning center that empowers K-12 students of all skill levels to excel in math.
Our approach goes beyond helping students with immediate needs like general schoolwork support. We like to say our tutors “are teaching for understanding” through a structured, proven, personalized learning experience.
Here’s how we help students overcome math misconceptions and build a deep understanding of the subject.
Unlike standard math curricula, the Mathnasium Method™ combines personalized learning plans with proven teaching techniques, guiding students toward a deep understanding of math concepts.
This approach helps each student build a solid foundation, addressing any misconceptions at their core.
Every student's journey with Mathnasium begins with a diagnostic assessment of their current skill level.
The assessment provides insights into their strengths and areas needing improvement and allows our tutors to understand each student's unique learning style and needs. With these insights, we develop a personalized plan to address knowledge gaps and correct any misconceptions.
At Mathnasium, students work with specially trained tutors in an engaging and supportive setting.
Our tutors break down problems into manageable steps and employ a variety of methods, including real-world applications, to help students develop critical thinking and problem-solving skills.
After enrolling at Mathnasium, students don’t just improve their math skills—they transform how they think and feel about math.
If you’re ready to unlock your student’s potential and set them on the path to math mastery, schedule a free assessment at our Cincinnati learning center today!
Schedule a Free Assessment at Mathnasium of Hyde Park
(513) 832-8773
(513) 832-8773
