"Optional" Standardized Testing: What the Data Showed in 2024

Jan 17, 2025 | Bayside

Here's the scoop on SATs and ACTs: Standardized tests are making a major comeback in college admissions, and strong test scores give you a clear advantage.

The Numbers are Eye-Opening

Admission data from recent years reveals striking differences in acceptance rates between test submitters and non-submitters at selective institutions:

  • Emory University: 17% acceptance rate for test submitters vs. 8.6% for non-submitters
  • Colgate University: 25% acceptance rate with test scores vs. 12% without
  • Georgia Tech: 22% acceptance rate with scores vs. 10% without
  • University of Georgia (Early Applications): 49% acceptance rate for submitters vs. 26% for non-submitters

The Shifting Landscape

Major universities are increasingly recognizing the value of standardized testing. Harvard, Yale, Brown, and Dartmouth announced they will require test scores for the Class of 2029, and more colleges are following in their footsteps every day. This shift comes as research shows test scores are strong predictors of college success.

Strategic Advantages

Submitting strong test scores can provide significant benefits:

  • At Georgetown, 90% of admitted students submitted scores, though only 80% of applicants did
  • At UVA, 42% applied test-optional, but 72% of accepted students had submitted scores
  • At Boston College, students who submitted scores had an 85% advantage in admission rates

Impact on Diversity and Access

Contrary to initial assumptions, test-optional policies haven't consistently improved access. Research from Dartmouth shows that test-optional policies can disadvantage high-achieving students from less privileged backgrounds. These students often choose not to submit scores that would have helped their applications when viewed in context.

Looking Ahead & Get Ahead

Strong test scores remain a valuable differentiator. Many four-year institutions maintain test-optional policies, but the data clearly shows that submitting competitive scores significantly enhances admission chances. So get ahead of it all. Set your child up for success and aim for a high SAT or ACT score!