If standard quantum theory holds up, imaginary numbers are critical.
To test how important imaginary numbers were in describing reality, the researchers used an updated version of the Bell test, an experiment which relies on quantum entanglement.(Image credit: Jurik Peter via Shutterstock)
Imaginary numbers are necessary to accurately describe reality, two new studies have suggested.
Imaginary numbers are what you get when you take the square root of a negative number, and they have long been used in the most important equations of quantum mechanics, the branch of physics that describes the world of the very small. When you add imaginary numbers and real numbers, the two form complex numbers, which enable physicists to write out quantum equations in simple terms. But whether quantum theory needs these mathematical chimeras or just uses them as convenient shortcuts has long been controversial.
In fact, even the founders of quantum mechanics themselves thought that the implications of having complex numbers in their equations was disquieting. In a letter to his friend Hendrik Lorentz, physicist Erwin Schrödinger — the first person to introduce complex numbers into quantum theory, with his quantum wave function (ψ) — wrote, "What is unpleasant here, and indeed directly to be objected to, is the use of complex numbers. Ψ is surely fundamentally a real function."
Schrödinger did find ways to express his equation with only real numbers alongside an additional set of rules for how to use the equation, and later physicists have done the same with other parts of quantum theory. But in the absence of hard experimental evidence to rule upon the predictions of these "all real" equations, a question has lingered: Are imaginary numbers an optional simplification, or does trying to work without them rob quantum theory of its ability to describe reality?
Now, two studies, published Dec. 15 in the journals Nature and Physical Review Letters, have proved Schrödinger wrong. By a relatively simple experiment, they show that if quantum mechanics is correct, imaginary numbers are a necessary part of the mathematics of our universe.
"The early founders of quantum mechanics could not find any way to interpret the complex numbers appearing in the theory," lead author Marc-Olivier Renou, a theoretical physicist at the Institute of Photonic Sciences in Spain, told Live Science in an email. "Having them [complex numbers] worked very well, but there is no clear way to identify the complex numbers with an element of reality."
To test whether complex numbers were truly vital, the authors of the first study devised a twist on a classic quantum experiment known as the Bell test. The test was first proposed by physicist John Bell in 1964 as a way to prove that quantum entanglement — the weird connection between two far-apart particles that Albert Einstein objected to as "spooky action at a distance" — was required by quantum theory.
In their updated version of the classic Bell test, the physicists devised an experiment in which two independent sources (which they called S and R) would be placed between three detectors (A, B and C) in an elementary quantum network. The source S would then emit two light particles, or photons — one sent to A and the other to B — in an entangled state. The source R also would emit two entangled photons, sending them to nodes B and C. If the universe were described by a standard quantum mechanics based on complex numbers, the photons that arrived at detectors A and C wouldn't need to be entangled, but in a quantum theory based on real numbers, they would.
To test this setup, the researchers of the second study performed an experiment in which they shone laser beams onto a crystal. The energy the laser gave to some of the crystals' atoms was later released as entangled photons. By looking at the states of the photons arriving at their three detectors, the researchers saw that the states of the photons arriving at detectors A and C weren't entangled, meaning their data could be described only by a quantum theory that used complex numbers.
The result makes intuitive sense; photons need to physically interact to become entangled, so those arriving at detectors A and C shouldn't be entangled if they're being produced by a different physical source. The researchers stressed, however, that their experiment only rules out theories that forgo imaginary numbers if the reigning conventions of quantum mechanics are correct. Most scientists are very confident that this is the case, but this is an important caveat nonetheless.
The result suggests that the possible ways we can describe the universe with math are actually much more constrained than we might have thought, Renou said.
"Just by observing what's coming out of some experiments, we can rule out many potential descriptions without making any assumptions [on the] reliability of the physical devices used in the experiment," Renou said. In the future, this could mean that it might just take a small number of experiments, building from first principles, for physicists to arrive at a complete quantum theory.
Beyond this, the researchers also said their experimental setup, which was a rudimentary quantum network, could be useful for outlining the principles on which a future quantum internet might operate.
Superb service and the staff are excellent. They exceed all our expectations and our kids are always eager to go to Mathnasium. They provide comprehensive feedback on progress and achievements. They work well with school teachers to address academic challenges at school.
My kids love the curriculum and the format of tutoring. They appreciate and enjoy mathematics more. The staff is great and we are quiet pleased with our experience this far and look forward to see our children sharpen their skills with mathnasium.
Hannah loves attending Mathnasium! She has grown her math confidence levels and enjoys working with the instructors. Miss Kaitlin always makes it convenient to change or update our schedule when needed.
In just a few short months, my daughter went from hating math and not doing well in it to this now being her favorite subject and is scoring straight A’s! we will definitely continue to use your services and recommend to others. Thank you Mathnasium.
My child enjoys attending Mathnasium and I believe it is enriching his Math skills and building his confidence. The initial intent for our family was for a Summer only program and we will continue year round to keep the positive momentum of learning going!
During the summer of 2020 I enrolled my son in mathnasium to help keep his math skills sharp. When school started I unenrolled him. Yesterday he told me he learned more at mathnasium in the summer compared to the entire school year so far. Mathnasium also helped him test into preallgebra going into 6th grade. Everyone at mathnasium is wonderful. Definitely worth the money!
I’m grateful for the confidence my daughter has gained in math and for the responsive rod the leadership team when i have a question or concern. I’m also grateful for the safety protocols during Covid. My only feedback now is a desire for more variety in prize choices. My daughter is asking to take a break as there are t items she is looking forward to earning. Any Harry Potter themed item would be a great addition to the prize cabinet.
Mathnasium - West County has been a very positive experience. Our transition from the Cottleville location to West County was seamless. We are extremely pleased with the protocols in place for COVID. The staff is taking all of the precautions to keep everyone safe. While COVID has disrupted quite a few things, it’s reassuring that Mathnasium - West County found a safe way to still meet in person for Math instruction for the families that are interested in this option. The online Mathnasium platform is great too! However, my son, Caleb, does better working in the center and the staff at Mathnasium are fantastic. They do a great job of working with each student, explaining new concepts, assisting with homework and making Math fun. Thank you!
Mathnasium has helped our children overcome their anxieties with math and get ahead in school. We can't say enough about how the staff has made such a difference in our kids' learning, along with how much they are proactive in communication with teachers and thinking ahead for their studies. We don't know what we would do without Mathnasium!
I really appreciate the personal care and attention my daughter receives at Mathnasium. It has changed her perspective on math and the confidence in her ability to solve problems. She now enjoys a subject she used to dread doing.
The partnership between Mathnasium and my son’s school has been a total game changer for such tasks as daily homework assignments and study guides for tests. The mentorship and assistance he receives in each visit has boosted his confidence and helped him achieve greater performance in the classroom.
Mathnasium is a kind, relaxing environment to build a positive attitude about math. My daughter loves Mathnasium because of the nice instructors, and the reward system. She can move at her own pace, which is above her grade level!!
We just started bringing our daughter to Mathnasium this summer so we don’t know how much she has improved yet. All we know is, our daughter would moan and groan every time she had to do math homework last year and she actually asks to go to Mathnasium!!
My daughter goes there almost everyday and she is very welling to go there, her math is much better than last year, and i am very happy to see this change. I am very grateful to the teachers in Mathnasium.
My child developed a new sense of confidence while attending Mathnasium. She literally asked each day if she could go to a session. Mathnasium was the best math intervention we’ve found for our child, and I’m a veteran teacher of 24 years!
Our daughter literally asks to go to Mathnasium, and she absolutely loves all of her teachers. Miss Jordan is a fabulous director! We’ve seen our daughter flourish and build confidence with a subject area that has plagued her in school. In a recent conversation, when asked if she enjoyed her hour of math class, she said, “I could go to Mathnasium for 100 hours!”
Mathnasium has been a wonderful in helping my daughter in mastering the skills she needs to be successful in mathematics. Before she began the Mathnasium program she was barely making C's and after a half a year in the program she is now making A's. Her confidence has risen significantly and she really enjoys going to Mathnasium. I am so happy that I have found Mathnasium for my daughter. I wish that there were more programs like Mathnasium out there and all children who are struggling in math could attend. Thank you Mathnasium for encouraging and giving my daughter the skills she needs to be proficient in math!
My son was struggling in Algebra, failing the first three quizzes and test. Mathnasium turned him around and gave him confidence. He finished the season with a solid B. He will be attending this summer to get ready for Geometry.
Kaitlin is the best! She is working very well with Sophie's teacher and SSD teacher at school to keep Sophie's lessons on track. What a great team Sophie has! I can show you tests from school before and after attending Mathnasium - went from 50% to 100% correct! I wish you could teach in the schools in place of her IEP!!
According to my daughter who has been going here for three plus years, The teachers here are very helpful and provide clear Instructions. They clarify all doubts and answer any number of questions the kids have. They do an incredible job and we are happy as our daughter is happy and loves to go here any time.
My fourth grade daughter was having self-esteem issues stemming primarily from having trouble at school and with homework. After trying other tutoring options we decided to give Mathnasium a shot. Her teacher has made several comments over the last few months regarding how much her attitude and school performance has improved – not only in math but across the board! Her attitude toward homework has not only improved, but the speed at which she is able to complete it has impressed all of us!
Thank you so much to each of the teachers at West County Mathnasium.
This experience has been so helpful for our daughter - her math skills have improved tremendously and she is now able to work independently with confidence.
Special thanks to Kaitlyn and Jubin, who showed patience, dedication and made learning math fun!
Our daughter gained an inner confidence that went beyond math and we are forever grateful for this great group of teachers!!
My daughter has been coming for several years now and her confidence in math specifically has increased exponentially and this has had a positive impact in her other classes as well. She knows if she doesn't understand something that she will be able to get it cleared up and continue moving forward. As a parent, I love the flexibility of not having a set time each week. We are able to be more consistent since we can work around schedule changes that occur from one week to the next. Thanks for all you do!
Mathnasium has succeeded in balancing out the learning of our daughter's core math skills, along with keeping her up to date on her 4th grade homework.
The teachers at Mathnasium are friendly, sincere and take the time to help her feel unique and accepted.
Our time at Mathasium has been beneficial for our entire family and has given our daughter a stronger sense of self and confidence.
We are very proud to be a part of Mathnasium!
Kaitlin Troy is fantastic as director of the Mathnasium center in West County, St. Louis, Missouri. She is truly helpful. She obviously cares deeply about coordinating the success of each student while effectively answering all questions from parents. The teachers at Mathnasium also care greatly about student success and have helped my daughter greatly.
This has been great for my daughter. She is motivated and happy to go. The assessment and the repetition has really helped her build those foundation skills. She is more able to easily answer verbal math questions which is something she had struggled with. It is great seeing her confidence grow.
My son's math grade has consistently gone up since attending Mathnasium when Kumon didn't. He actually likes to go and Mathnasium has been responsive to requests such as focusing on ACT test questions.
The Faculty and teachers are very courteous and helpful.
Staff here is phenomenal.
Center understands parents and kids schedule.
The admin adjusts the schedule and hours during peak seasons ,where kids are involved in multiple activities in school .
The center is ready to alter kids math syllablus .
My daughter was really down on herself about math and it was a constant struggle to get her to spend time working on math at home. We tried flash cards, apps, online games, workbooks... and she fought them all. She LOVES going to Mathnasium and is growing leaps and bounds in her confidence with math.
My daughter enjoys going to Mathnasium and asks to go, and she has asked to continue once school starts. We tried a private tutor before attending Mathnasium, but she complained each time and disliked going. She really enjoys the teachers at Mathnasium.
We haven't been able to go as often as I had hoped, but I have been happy with the sessions so far. I would love for there to be morning hours at least one day a week during the summer, but I understand that may not be possible. We are happy with everything so far. Thanks!
To find out more about cookies or learn how to change your cookie settings, please see our